Side-selling
Side-selling is the sale of produce by a farmer to a buyer other than the cooperative, company or programme they are contracted to or registered with, often for immediate cash or a better price. It breaks the link between registered plots and delivered volumes.
Also known as: side selling · extra-contractual sales · leakage
Why does it matter?
Side-selling cuts both ways. Registered volumes leak out, weakening the business case of cooperatives and sustainability programmes. Unregistered volumes also leak in: a buyer receiving produce from farmers side-selling from other programmes may be buying from plots it has never assessed.
For traceability, the risk is that declared plots and physical volumes no longer match.
What causes it?
- Need for immediate cash, especially before harvest payments.
- Price differences between buyers.
- Late payment or unreliable services from the contracted buyer.
- Debt or pre-financing from other traders.
How can data help detect it?
- Yield plausibility: deliveries far above or below what the farmer’s plots can produce.
- Cross-buyer checks: the same farmer or plot selling to several buyers beyond its capacity.
- Timing anomalies: deliveries outside the local harvest season.
These checks require farmer identities consistent across buyers, which relies on deduplication and on buyers agreeing to pool these checks.
Common pitfalls
- Treating side-selling purely as disloyalty, without addressing payment and price.
- Checking only within one company’s data.
Cross-buyer volume checks are part of Farmer1st’s pre-competitive fraud detection service.
Frequently asked questions
Is side-selling illegal?
Usually not. Farmers are generally free to sell to whom they choose unless bound by a contract. It is a commercial and data problem more than a legal one.
How can side-selling be reduced?
Common levers include prompt payment, transparent pricing and premiums, pre-financing and services that reward loyalty, and data that makes farmers' own records portable so they gain from staying in a programme.
Tell us about your supply chain.
Ten minutes with our scoping assistant. We come back with a first sketch of your service.
